LH: Gov’t will violate ESI in 2009

La’o Hamutuk
Timor-Leste Institute for Development Monitoring and Analysis
I/1a Rua Mozambique, Farol, Dili, Timor-Leste
Tel: +670 332 5013 email: info@laohamutuk.org Website: http://www.laohamutuk.org

10 November 2009

To: Dr. Manuel Tilman
President and members of Committee C, RDTL National Parliament

CC: (1) Minister of Finance, Banking and Payments Authority,
President of Parliament (and Heads of Parties in Parliament),
Deloitte, Media, Petroleum Fund Consultative Council

Dear Mr. President and Members of Committee C, with our respect,

On 4 November, La’o Hamutuk made a submission to your Committee stating that:
“La’o Hamutuk agrees with the Government not to withdraw more than
the Estimated Sustainable Income of $502 million from the Petroleum
Fund during 2010, and we appreciate that spending will stay below the
ESI during 2009, as it did during 2008, notwithstanding budgetary
dreams to spend unsustainably.”

One week later, we learned that the Ministry of Finance had
instructed the Banking and Payments Authority (BPA) to transfer a
total of $512 million from the Petroleum Fund during 2009, including
$152 million in December. This contradicts promises made when the
Government presented the draft General State Budget for 2010 to
Parliament on 15 October. Pages 16 and 28 of Book 1 (English
version), say that the Government will not transfer more money than
the Estimated Sustainable Income (ESI), $408 million, from the
Petroleum Fund during 2009.

La’o Hamutuk regrets that the information we relied on in our
submission to your Committee is no longer correct, and we too are
surprised that the Government will withdraw $104 million more than
the ESI during 2009. This will reduce the ESI in every future year by
$3.1 million, including in 2010.

Therefore, the plan in the 2010 draft budget to transfer $502 million
from the Petroleum Fund in 2010 is higher than the ESI will be ($499
million). Consequently, the draft budget violates Article 9 of the
Petroleum Fund Law, which requires the Government to provide a
detailed explanation when it proposes to transfer more than the ESI.

We believe that Parliament has a critical responsibility to examine
and improve State Finances, and it is therefore important for you to
know that there is an inconsistency between what the Government
presented in the Budget Documents and what they are actually doing.
You might want to ask the Ministry of Finance to provide further information.

On a related topic, you have seen the 4 November letter from the
Prime Minister to the President of Parliament (Ref. No
1981/GPM/XI/09) spelling out changes in the design and enlargement of
the heavy oil electricity generation and distribution project. These
alterations will increase the project cost far beyond the original
$375 million allocated in the 2009 State Budget (as discussed on
pages 11 and 12 of our Submission on the 2010 State Budget). The
Prime Minister’s letter increases our concern that the appropriation
for this project in the draft 2010 State Budget ($48 million in 2010,
$73 million total) could be half a billion dollars less than the
actual project cost. It seems likely that the Government plans to
borrow this money (perhaps from China). Before approving the 2010
State Budget (which increasingly looks like an interim budget, with
many major decisions being put off until a rectification a few months
from now), we encourage Committee C to seek a full explanation of how
much this revised project will cost, how it will be financed, and how
any loan will be paid back.

We remain aware that the Petroleum Fund not only has to provide for
today’s generation, but also must support the lives of our children
and grandchildren, and should be used for sustainable development of
non-oil sectors, as we all know that our oil and gas resources will
run out in less than a generation. We believe that you and other
members of Committee C share our perspective and concerns.

Thank you for your attention. We hope that this information is
helpful and welcome any comments or questions you may have for us.


Juvinal Dias, Charles Scheiner, Viriato Seac
La’o Hamutuk Natural Resources Team


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s