The National (Abu Dhabi)
East Timor debates use of oil richesMarianne Kearney, Foreign
Correspondent Last Updated: August 26. 2008 10:31PM UAE / August 26.
2008 6:31PM GMT
DILI // Plans to build a massive new power station in East Timor have
stirred debate over the use of the tiny and impoverished country’s oil
profits amid fears the government is squandering its hard-won oil and
The US$390 million (Dh1.43 billion) power station would be the largest
project built in the country, where power blackouts are frequent and
many areas lack access to the electricity grid.
But critics have objected to the plant, both because of its use of
imported heavy oil, a technology mostly considered outdated in the West
due to its polluting by-products, such as sulphur, and because it is to
be partially funded by dipping into the country’s protected oil and gas
funds. This month, the opposition Fretilin Party refused to sign off on
the budget because it included funding for the plant.
We put forward a vote in parliament to eliminate funding for a heavy
oil power station in favour of the government exploring renewable
energy initiatives, said Jose Teixeira, an opposition spokesman and
former state secretary for natural resources.
With few other resources apart from oil and gas, East Timor established
one of the world’s most progressive oil-fund laws, modelled on
Norway’s: just three per cent of its profits can be used for public
spending; the rest is saved in a sovereign US-based fund that will be
used for future East Timor generations.
The country enacted the law to avoid the resource curse: oil- and
gas-rich countries squandering their money on expensive projects, with
much of the oil profits ending up in the pockets of the elite and
little of the wealth trickling down to ordinary citizens.
Jose Ramos-Horta, the president, opposition figures and donors fear the
government under Xanana Gusmao, a former guerrilla fighter, plans to
recklessly spend a huge portion of the oil money.
The almost $800m midyear budget is more than twice what was budgeted
for the first six months of 2008. It also proposes to withdraw an
additional $290m of oil funds above the level considered sustainable.
If this continues, we fear there will be no money left for East
Timor’s future, said Viriato Seac, from La’o Hamutuk, a local group
that monitors the government and the oil and gas industry.
Mr Ramos-Horta said he would refuse to pass the budget into law, as
there was widespread objection, both at home and among such donors as
the World Bank and International Monetary Fund to the use of additional
However, one day after publicly criticising the budget, he said his
office accidentally signed off on it after he had left on a trip to
China. He issued an apology.
The Fretilin Party has also argued that the budget, which would spend
$600m in just five months, could lead to corruption.
[There are] big increases for overseas travel for ministers, luxury
four-wheel drive cars for MPs and cars for civil servants. The money
will just disappear and risk the rise of both corruption and
inflation, Mr Teixeira said.
The state secretary for electricity and water has vowed to push on with
the electricity station, arguing East Timor desperately needs power if
its economy is to grow.
We need to deliver electricity quickly to the people, Januario da
He argued that more environmentally friendly types of stations, such
the hydro-powered plant currently supplying power to eastern Timor,
take too long to build. We’ve been building the Iralalaro
hydroelectric power station from 2003 until now, and it’s still not
complete, he said.
The government has argued that public spending is necessary to combat
the high unemployment and social unrest plaguing much of the remote,
mountainous country, since the outbreak of violence and instability in
Tens of thousands of people were displaced during the crisis, most of
whom have only recently returned to their homes. East Timor also has
been severely hit by rising global oil and food prices, and part of the
budget will be used to subsidise the cost of basic foods.
Sources within the finance ministry are particularly concerned with the
large amount of money allocated for the power station, and the $240m to
subsidise food and other basic necessities.
No previous government ever spent more than $180m a year, how will
they spend over $770m this year? asked one foreign adviser in the
Critics also said the government may have already chosen a company to
build the power station and grid, because it allowed just three weeks
for international companies to put in an expression of interest.
Mr Costa denied there was any favoured tenderer and said despite the
short time period, 14 multinational companies, including those from
Australia and Singapore, had submitted proposals.
Mr Teixeira, the opposition spokesman, said the country needed projects
that created employment and upgraded infrastructure, but said he feared
the electricity station would be a white elephant that squandered
the country’s future.
East Timor is one of Asia’s poorest countries and has struggled for
years to obtain the billions of dollars in revenue from its oil and gas
Australia, which originally signed an agreement with former conquering
power Indonesia, initially claimed it should have the right to 50 per
cent of the oil and gas fields in the Timor Sea, based on an earlier
deal with Jakarta. But since 2002, East Timor has argued that under
current maritime laws 90 per cent of the fields would be considered
within its sea boundaries.